Guest Commentary
WSJ: „An Urgent Need to Contain Turkey“

A guest commentary by Özgür Çelik on the debate in the Wall Street Journal about the strategic “containment” of Turkey and its new role in the Middle East.

Teilen

Guest Commentary: Özgür Çelik

The article „An Urgent Need to Contain Turkey,“ written by Bradley Martin and published in the Wall Street Journal on March 4, 2026, appears at first glance to be a commentary on Middle Eastern power dynamics. However, it formulates a far more reaching strategic recommendation. The text argues that any power vacuum created by a potential weakening of Iranian influence in the region must not be filled by Turkey.

According to the author, the U.S. and Israel should already incorporate this possibility into their strategic planning. The central message is clear: following Iran, Turkey could emerge as the next rising actor in the Middle East—a prospect that Western strategic circles must monitor closely.

The Wall Street Journal’s Strategic Recommendation

Upon closer inspection of the language used, it becomes apparent that the criticism directed at Turkey targets a much broader framework than individual political decisions. The article relies on several lines of argument: Turkey is portrayed as a difficult NATO partner, pursuing a Middle East policy independent of the Western line, failing to align fully with Washington regarding Iran, and utilizing regional crises for its own strategic advantage.

Turkey as a NATO Partner Under Scrutiny

In this context, Turkey is depicted not merely as a criticized ally, but as a power that—if necessary—must be limited or „contained.“ It is particularly striking that Turkey is openly described for the first time as an „actor that must be kept in balance.“ The term „contain“ is by no means an ordinary expression in international politics.

The Concept of „Containment“: A Historical Turning Point

Historically, it represents a strategic approach used by great powers to balance rising or independently acting states through political, military, or economic means. The use of this term in relation to Turkey suggests that certain Western circles no longer view Ankara solely as an ally, but simultaneously as a potential rival power center.

Focus on State Capacity Rather Than Specific Policies

Another notable aspect of the text is that the discussion does not focus on a specific government or individual political leaders, but on overall state capacity. The article does not limit itself to criticizing specific Turkish decisions.

Instead, military strength, geographic location, and regional influence potential are analyzed collectively to discuss the future geopolitical role this potential might play. This approach reflects a classic reflex in international politics: states that could gain significant influence are analyzed early, and strategies are devised to maintain a balance of power.

Power Dynamics in the International System

Such texts often trigger emotional reactions. However, it is more important to understand what they actually convey. In the international system, states are judged neither on the basis of permanent friendships nor permanent enmities.

The perception of states is primarily shaped by power relations. When a country becomes an influential actor in its region, it is not uncommon for other power centers to consider how that influence might be limited or balanced.

Perceived Potential as a Trigger for Western Concern

In this sense, the article is more than just a collection of criticisms against Turkey; it serves as a warning regarding future shifts in power within the Middle East. While a potential decline in Iranian influence is discussed, Turkey already appears in the text as the next defining actor. This can be read as an indicator of how the perception of Turkey is shifting within the international system.

Demands for the „containment“ of a state usually arise from the assessment that its influence is poised to grow. Therefore, the views formulated in the article should be understood not just as polemical debate, but as a document of how Turkey’s role is perceived in global politics.

 


THIS MIGHT ALSO INTEREST YOU

– World –
The Economist: Erdogan most popular politician in the Muslim world

Analysis from The Economist and Arab Barometer confirms President Erdogan is the leading voice for the world’s 2 billion Muslims, a journey that began with his 2009 Davos protest.

The Economist: Erdogan most popular politician in the Muslim world

Auch interessant

Antalya: Zehn Tage zwischen Hoffnung und Zweifel

Ein Gastkommentar von Özgür Çelik Seit Montag verhandeln in Antalya Zehntausende Delegierte über das Klima der Erde, in einer Stadt, die sonst vor allem für Strandurlaub...

Hamilton trifft Gaza-Kinder: „Hat mir das Herz gebrochen“

Al-Arish – Der siebenfache Formel-1-Weltmeister Lewis Hamilton hat in Ägypten palästinensische Kinder getroffen, die aus dem Gazastreifen evakuiert wurden. Die Begegnung habe ihm „das...

Rubio: Israel soll Waffen künftig selbst bezahlen

Paris – Nach der Wahlniederlage der Republikaner nennen führende Republikaner, darunter Präsident Donald Trump und Vizepräsident JD Vance, den Iran-Krieg und das Verhältnis zu...

Mattner: Bremer „Wolf im Schafspelz“-Kampagne war ein Fehler

Ein Gastkommentar von Susanne Mattner Der Wolf im Schafspelz. Ausgerechnet Muslime. Und plötzlich soll das alles ganz normale Gefahrenabwehr sein? Ganz ehrlich: Ich finde, die...

Gerichtsunterlagen: Playboy-Gründer Hugh Hefner soll FBI 2005 vor Epstein gewarnt haben

Washington - Der verstorbene Playboy-Gründer Hugh Hefner soll das US-Bundespolizeiamt FBI bereits im Jahr 2005 mehrfach vor dem Sexualstraftäter Jeffrey Epstein gewarnt haben. Das...

Headlines

EU-Superwahljahr 2027: Warum Brüssel eine neue Blockade droht

Ein Gastkommentar Özgür Çelik 2027 wählen Frankreich, Italien, Spanien und Polen. Zusammen stellen sie 47,5 Prozent der EU-Bevölkerung. Es geht...

Mamdani: Zahl der Drogentoten sinkt auf niedrigsten Stand seit 2019

NYC - In New York City ist die Zahl der Todesfälle durch Drogenüberdosierungen deutlich zurückgegangen und hat den niedrigsten...

USA: Erster muslimischer Senator El-Sayed will Eid auf Jefferson-Koran ablegen

Washington - Nach einem erbittert geführten Wahlkampf, in dem US-Präsident Donald Trump ihn als „Dschihadisten“ bezeichnet und gefordert hatte,...

Netanjahu-Rivale Eisenkot verurteilt „Rassismus gegen Araber“

Tel Aviv - Der mit der Regierungsbildung beauftragte israelische Oppositionspolitiker Gadi Eisenkot hat dem geschäftsführenden Ministerpräsidenten Benjamin Netanjahu eine...

Meinung

EU-Superwahljahr 2027: Warum Brüssel eine neue Blockade droht

Ein Gastkommentar Özgür Çelik 2027 wählen Frankreich, Italien, Spanien und Polen. Zusammen stellen sie 47,5 Prozent der EU-Bevölkerung. Es geht dabei nicht um rechts oder...

Mattner: Bremer „Wolf im Schafspelz“-Kampagne war ein Fehler

Ein Gastkommentar von Susanne Mattner Der Wolf im Schafspelz. Ausgerechnet Muslime. Und plötzlich soll das alles ganz normale Gefahrenabwehr sein? Ganz ehrlich: Ich finde, die...

CHP: Vatandaşlar ile Parti Arasındaki Artan Kopuş

Nabi Yücel Vatandaşlarla partiler arasındaki giderek derinleşen kopuş, Türkiye'nin en köklü partisi CHP üzerinden somut biçimde gözlemlenebilir. Cumhuriyet Halk Partisi, 38. Olağan Kurultay'ın ardından ve...

Araştırma: Dini İnanç, Gençleri Kaygı Bozukluklarından Koruyan Temel Bir Faktör

Almanya - Bochum Ruhr Üniversitesi (RUB) tarafından yürütülen güncel bir araştırma, dini inancın çocukların ve gençlerin ruh sağlığı için kritik bir koruyucu faktör olduğunu...

Araştırma: ChatGPT kullanımı beyin aktivitesini önemli ölçüde azaltıyor

Cambridge – MIT Media Lab tarafından yapılan bir araştırma, ChatGPT ve diğer AI asistanlarının kullanımının beyin aktivitesini büyük ölçüde azalttığına dair ilk kanıtları sunuyor. Araştırma,...